Thinking of Making Custom Acrylic Keychains? All That Printing’s Ultimate Material Guide

Keychains are more than just accessories; they are a statement of your personal taste and vibe. Custom acrylic keychains have become a massive trend for those wanting to express their unique identity. But with so many options at All That Printing, which one should you choose?

The "temperature" of your final result changes entirely depending on the material you choose for your design. Whether it’s your first time or you're a pro, here is a guide to finding the perfect match for your style.

01. Minimalists: For Those Who Love Clean Aesthetics

#Essentials #BasicItem #Timeless #Clean

This lineup is for those who appreciate the inherent transparency and neatness of the material. These basics blend seamlessly with any bag or accessory.

[Clear Acrylic] The gold standard of custom keychains. Its high transparency ensures your design looks crisp and vivid. All That Printing’s clear acrylic is resistant to yellowing, maintaining its clarity for a long time.

[Astel (Matte)] A soft, frosted material that is resistant to fingerprints. With less light reflection than standard acrylic, it offers a sophisticated, premium feel—perfect for modern brand logos.

[Pastel Mute Baby Colors] These acrylics feature soft, desaturated tones that offer a more comfortable and sophisticated feel than vivid primary colors. They perfectly complement emotional line drawings or watercolor-style illustrations, creating a moody aesthetic even without a printed background.

[Pastel Astel 4T (Double-sided Semi-transparent)] A premium 4mm thick material with a double-sided matte finish. It has a dreamy, candy-like translucency that feels like a high-end object.

02. Scene Stealers: For a Bold Presence

#EyeCatching #Shine #UniqueDesign

For those who want their keychain to stand out everywhere. These materials look stunning, especially under natural sunlight.

[Glitter Acrylic] Infused with fine pearl glitter that sparkles brilliantly. Highly recommended for idol merch or designs that need a magical, vibrant touch.

[Hologram Acrylic] Features a shattered glass or grid pattern that glows with rainbow colors. The shifting hues at different angles ensure there’s never a dull moment.

[Half-Mirror] Reflects the background like a mirror while maintaining transparency. It creates a dreamy, urban aesthetic that changes its look depending on where it's hung.

[Lenticular Keychain] A high-tech material where the image changes or moves depending on your perspective. Perfect for "Day & Night" concepts or characters with two different expressions.

03. Smart Workers: Practicality Meets Fun

#SmartItems #Pragmatism #Witty

This lineup is perfect for those seeking more than just decoration—something functional for daily use or with satisfying structural mechanics. If you're looking to create a truly practical acrylic keychain, we recommend keeping an eye on our specialized mirror or glow-in-the-dark materials.

[Mirror Acrylic] The back is an actual mirror. It’s incredibly useful for quick touch-ups on the go, making it a favorite for female-targeted merchandise.

[Spinning Keychain] A 3D structure where the center spins within a frame. It’s addictive and fun, much like a fidget toy.

[Glow-in-the-Dark] Looks like clean white acrylic during the day but emits a soft green glow in the dark. A great choice for camping gear or night-time events.

04. Heritage Lovers: Traditional Elegance

#SubtleGloss #NacreAesthetic #Sophisticated

This collection offers a modern reinterpretation of the traditional mother-of-pearl (nacre) aesthetic. These materials are highly recommended for custom acrylic keychains intended as thoughtful gifts for elders or international friends, as well as for those who appreciate a calm, sophisticated sense of luxury.

[Hologram Mother-of-Pearl (Nacre)] Captures the mysterious, iridescent glow of natural nacre within acrylic. It turns a simple piece of merch into a work of art, especially when paired with traditional patterns or calligraphy.

[Mother-of-Pearl Mirror Keychain (Hand Mirror Keychain)] This elegant keychain combines the iridescent beauty of traditional mother-of-pearl with a practical back-side mirror. It is a premium choice for those seeking sophisticated, Korean-inspired gifts or high-end merchandise.

05. High-End Collectors: Quality and Detail Above All

#HeavyWeight #PermanentPreservation #Masterpiece

Our high-end lineup is designed for those who seek a level of weight and craftsmanship that is in a class of its own compared to ordinary keychains. If you want to achieve professional-grade, high-quality results, we suggest choosing the 5T (5mm) thickness to elevate your custom creation.

[Extra Thick Clear 5T] Uses 5mm acrylic, significantly thicker than the standard 3mm. The depth and weight give the keychain a luxurious, high-end feel.

[Half Mirror 5T] This premium 5mm material enhances the half-mirror’s dreamy reflection with an impressive sense of depth. It delivers a luxurious, substantial feel, making it the perfect choice for high-end, professional-grade collectibles.

[Sandwich Printing (Double-sided Acrylic) 5T] The print is "sandwiched" between two layers of acrylic. This prevents any scratching and gives the image a mysterious, encased look.

Package Keychain (Gacha Style)] A DIY-style set where you assemble the character and its packaging. This is currently the hottest item among collectors for its "toy-box" aesthetic.

Editor's Note 

Which material speaks to your style? Even with the same design, the choice of material can turn your artwork into a completely different masterpiece. Choose your favorite at All That Printing today and start creating your one-of-a-kind, high-quality acrylic keychain!